**Kylebooker X-Select Dubbing – Deer Ear / Hares Ear – Fly Tying Materials: A Review of Its Value for Money**
For fly-tying enthusiasts, selecting high-quality dubbing materials is crucial for creating realistic and durable flies. The **Kylebooker X-Select Dubbing** in *Deer Ear* and *Hares Ear* variants has gained attention among anglers, but how does it stack up in terms of cost-effectiveness? This review explores its performance, durability, and overall value to help you decide if it’s worth adding to your fly-tying toolkit.
### **1. Quality and Texture**
The **X-Select Dubbing** stands out for its fine, natural fibers, which mimic the texture of real deer and hare fur. Unlike synthetic blends, this material offers superior lifelike movement in water, making it ideal for nymphs, emergers, and dry flies. The fibers are slightly coarse yet manageable, allowing for easy blending and adherence to threads. Compared to budget options, the **X-Select** avoids clumping and maintains consistency, reducing waste during tying.
### **2. Versatility in Fly Patterns**
Both the *Deer Ear* and *Hares Ear* colors are versatile for imitating a range of aquatic insects. The natural hues blend seamlessly with other materials, and the dubbing can be applied thinly for sparse patterns or densely for buggy profiles. Tested in patterns like the *Hare’s Ear Nymph* and *CDC Emergers*, the material retains its shape even after multiple casts, proving its durability.
### **3. Durability and Longevity**
A key factor in assessing value is longevity. Cheap dubbing often sheds or degrades after a few fish, but the **X-Select** holds up well against teeth and abrasion. The fibers are long enough for durability yet short enough for smooth application. A single bag (typically 5–10 grams) can tie dozens of flies, making it cost-efficient over time.
### **4. Price Comparison**
At a mid-range price point (around $8–$12 per bag), the **Kylebooker X-Select** is pricier than synthetic bulk dubbing but more affordable than premium hand-blended options. Given its quality, it strikes a balance—ideal for tiers who want natural materials without overspending. Competitors like *Wapsi* or *Hareline* offer similar products, but **Kylebooker**’s consistent texture gives it an edge.
### **5. User Feedback**
Online reviews highlight the dubbing’s ease of use and realistic finish. Some users note that the *Deer Ear* variant is slightly finer than traditional hare’s ear, offering subtle differences for selective trout. A minority mention that the packaging could be sturdier, but this doesn’t affect performance.
### **Final Verdict: Is It Worth It?**
For anglers prioritizing quality and natural appearance, the **Kylebooker X-Select Dubbing** delivers excellent value. While not the cheapest option, its durability, versatility, and realistic results justify the cost. If you tie flies regularly and seek materials that enhance your patterns’ effectiveness, this dubbing is a smart investment.
**Rating: 4.5/5** (Docked slightly for packaging, but performance excels).
*Pro Tip*: Pair it with a waxed thread for better adhesion, and store it in a dry container to extend its lifespan. Happy tying!
(Word count: 520)